Christmas Close Reading Mystery Inference Activity - Who Stole Santa's Gifts?

This Christmas reading activity is a highly engaging way to strengthen close reading, inference, and evidence-based reasoning skills during the holiday season. Students are challenged to slow down, reread carefully, and piece together clues as they work collaboratively to solve a festive Christmas mystery of who stole Santa's gifts! Throughout the activity, students must analyze multiple text types, justify their conclusions with text evidence, and think critically about motive, opportunity, and evidence. With everything included and minimal prep required, this Christmas mystery is perfect for keeping students focused and learning during the busy weeks leading up to winter break.

Christmas Mystery Backstory: On the night before Christmas, Santa’s sleigh sets off with the first round of presents. After heading down the first chimney to enjoy some milk and cookies, Santa returns to his sleigh only to discover something has gone terribly wrong—the gifts have vanished! Whether the presents were stolen back at the North Pole or during Santa’s cookie break, it’s up to your students to analyze the evidence, make logical inferences, and determine who is responsible before Christmas is ruined.

➡️ Christmas Mystery PowerPoint Presentation: This 15-slide PowerPoint presentation guides the entire Christmas mystery from start to finish. It introduces the backstory, presents each piece of evidence, walks students through suspect elimination, and concludes with a clear culprit reveal. The presentation also includes detailed explanations for why each suspect is innocent or guilty, making whole-class review and discussion seamless.

➡️ “Who Stole the Gifts from Santa’s Sleigh?” Classroom Poster: Build excitement the moment students enter the room by displaying this eye-catching poster on your classroom door or wall. It immediately hooks students into the Christmas mystery and sets the stage for collaborative problem-solving.

➡️ Christmas Mystery Narrative Backstory: This engaging short story sets up the Christmas mystery by explaining how Santa discovers the gifts are missing from his sleigh on Christmas Eve. As students read, they encounter small but important details woven into the narrative that hint at what may have happened, requiring them to read closely and begin making inferences right from the start.

➡️ A Variety of Clues and Evidence: Students analyze multiple forms of evidence that require careful reading and logical reasoning. These include an email, text message, naughty or nice list, letter, Santa’s Workshop incident report, a note from a child, a petition, and a social media message conversation. Each piece of evidence adds depth to the Christmas mystery and challenges students to synthesize information across texts.

➡️ “Who Destroyed the Snowman?” Graphic Organizer: Students use this graphic organizer to track clues, record inferences, and eliminate suspects. It provides a structured way for students to organize their thinking and justify their conclusions with evidence.

➡️ Teacher Answer Key: A complete answer key is provided in both print format and within the presentation slides, making it easy to review reasoning, facilitate discussion, or quickly check student work.

How This Close Reading Inference Mystery Christmas Reading Activity Works:

• Start by displaying the poster on your classroom door or wall to immediately build curiosity and anticipation. Place students into small groups so they can collaborate, discuss evidence, and share ideas as they work through the Christmas mystery.
  
• Use the presentation slides to introduce the story and guide students through each piece of evidence step by step.
  
• Distribute the evidence documents and allow groups time to close read, make inferences, and develop their final predictions.
  
• Once all groups have reached a conclusion, reveal the culprit using the presentation and walk through the evidence together to explain why each suspect is innocent or guilty.

What Teachers Are Saying About This Close Reading Inference Mystery Christmas Reading Activity:

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ This resource was easy to use, low prep, and highly engaging! Thank you for making my life easier with this resource!

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ What a fantastic way to practice making inferences, critical thinking, and solving a mystery! The holiday themed made it even more appealing to students right before winter break.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ This Christmas activity resource was a hit with my students! It brought a festive spirit to the classroom while providing engaging and educational activities. The students enjoyed every moment and were excited to participate.

→ Who Destroyed the Snowman?

© Presto Plans